The characters were very dynamic but underdeveloped. They hinted at some of their background but they did not elaborate on much of it, especially with Kambei and Kikuchiyo. Kambei never gave any information on his past and his relations with some of the other samurai. They acknowledged that he knew them and that they were friends but never went deeper. Kikuchiyo had a past with adapting a samurai’s persona but not truly being one that was not explained as well. Kurosawa concentrated more on the philosophy of the story than the characters in it.
The acting was pretty good but there were a few moments where the emotion just did not seem believable but the dialog in the movie was pretty good throughout. The costumes and the setting were authentic to
On the more positive side, the movie did a great job of showing the difference in classes. It creates struggles with the town and trying to get help and it also causes Kikuchiyo problems when trying to becoming one of the group. The class problems also create tension when the father of Shino does not want her to fall in love with a samurai because of the class difference and it eventually leads to a love conflict in the end that is never resolved.
Much of this movie I could probably understand better if I knew more about the Japanese culture. Many of the things in here were cultural and it was assumed that the watcher would know what is going on. I did not understand many of the characters’ gestures and phrases to each other because of this. It may have made the acting, especially, more believable if I had known these things. For the most part the movie was good and I would recommend that you see it but just expect it to be a little slow in some parts and there to be missing some of the background information.
3 comments:
Wrong: this movie was great. You really have to be in a Seven SAmarui mood, but dont tell me that you didn't bleive the acting! From beginning to end all i did was see this movie, not just watch it. It was amazing in my mind...mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.... good movie....
This review does not have very many specifics, and it did not help me know if i wanted to see the movie or not. How was it authentic looking? What props were authentic? How can you know what "authentic looking" looks like if you later say that you do not know much about Japanese culture?
I liked your review. You did a good job of explaining your views on it. I agree that there could have been a few more specifics but overall it was a quality review.
Post a Comment